Scope
This AAOS guideline addresses assessment, surgical choices, associated injuries and prevention in anterior cruciate ligament injury. Treatment should reflect activity goals, skeletal maturity, associated pathology and shared decisions. Strong recommendations for particular surgical choices apply once surgery is indicated; they do not establish that every ACL tear requires reconstruction.
Written by House with AI assistance · AI-assisted source check 29 October 2026.
This is House’s summary of the cited guidance. The source check is not an independent clinician review. Open the publication for complete recommendations, exceptions, evidence grades and later amendments.
Assess the injury and patient goals
- Obtain a relevant history and focused lower-limb musculoskeletal examination for suspected ACL injury. Ask about the injury mechanism and date, a pop, weight bearing, return to play, locking or catching, pain location and previous knee injuries. [1]
- The focused examination should document distal perfusion and tibial/peroneal nerve function, assess varus–valgus and rotational laxity, and evaluate anterior–posterior instability using appropriate tests such as Lachman, anterior drawer and pivot shift. [1]
- Discuss available treatments and their relative risks and benefits with the patient and, when appropriate, a parent or guardian. Include age, activity demands and associated meniscal or cartilage injury in the decision between reconstruction and nonoperative care. [1]
- A painful, tense knee effusion after injury may be aspirated, based on consensus rather than reliable efficacy evidence. Potential pain and motion benefits must be weighed against introducing infection. [1]
Select reconstruction and its timing
- Reconstruction may be considered to reduce future meniscal pathology or procedures, particularly in younger or more active patients, and may improve long-term pain and function. This is a limited-strength option; comparative long-term outcome evidence remains incomplete. [1]
- When surgery is indicated for an acute isolated ACL tear, prefer early reconstruction because additional meniscal and cartilage injury begins increasing within 3 months. This strong recommendation does not override an appropriate nonoperative decision in an older, less active patient. [1]
- For ACL tears selected for surgery, the guideline strongly recommends reconstruction rather than repair because reconstruction has a lower revision-surgery risk. [1]
Individualize graft and reconstruction choices
- Either single-bundle or double-bundle intra-articular reconstruction can be considered because measured outcomes are similar. Double-bundle surgery generally takes longer and costs more; the source does not establish superior functional benefit. [1]
- Consider autograft over allograft to improve outcomes and reduce graft failure, particularly in young or active patients. This is a strong recommendation; discuss the additional harvest-related pain or functional morbidity when choosing the graft. [1]
- For skeletally mature patients receiving an autograft, bone–patellar tendon–bone may be favoured to lower graft-failure or infection risk, while hamstring graft may be favoured to reduce anterior or kneeling pain. This is a moderate-strength recommendation; choose according to the patient’s priorities. [1]
- In selected patients having hamstring-autograft ACL reconstruction, anterolateral ligament reconstruction or lateral extra-articular tenodesis may reduce failure and improve short-term function. The recommendation is moderate; long-term effects remain uncertain, and extra incisions, implants and anaesthesia time add potential risk. [1]
Preserve joint structures where appropriate
- With an ACL tear and accompanying meniscal tear, consider meniscal preservation to optimize joint health and function. This is a limited-strength option; repair may require later knee surgery, and the reviewed evidence does not establish that it prevents osteoarthritis. [1]
- In combined ACL and MCL tears, nonoperative MCL treatment can give good outcomes, although selected cases may warrant MCL surgery. This limited-strength option requires individual assessment rather than assuming every combined injury needs MCL reconstruction. [1]
Prevent injury and assess return to sport
- Athletes in high-risk sports may use structured injury-prevention training to reduce primary ACL injuries. This is a moderate-strength recommendation; effective participation also depends on practical demands such as time, equipment, space and motivation. [1]
- Prophylactic knee bracing is not the preferred approach to preventing ACL injury. Its uncertain benefit should not displace participation in injury-prevention exercise programmes; the recommendation has limited strength. [1]
- After reconstruction, a functional test such as a hop test may inform return-to-sport decisions, but only as one factor. Optimal testing and return timing remain uncertain; passing a hop test alone does not establish safe clearance. [1]
- Do not routinely prescribe a functional knee brace for return to activity after isolated primary ACL reconstruction: the guideline finds no demonstrated clinical benefit. This limited-strength recommendation should not be automatically extended to combined ligament injuries or other populations not addressed by it. [1]
Limitations and use
- This summarizes the published AAOS guideline and its clinical rationale; it is not a complete operative technique, imaging algorithm, rehabilitation programme or return-to-sport clearance protocol. It does not establish a universal return-to-sport time or numerical hop-test threshold. The graft-source comparison specifically concerns skeletally mature patients; do not automatically apply it across open growth plates. Some options have limited evidence or consensus support despite stronger evidence for other recommendations.
This summary is selective and does not reproduce every recommendation. Apply the source’s population, setting and eligibility criteria, together with clinical judgement and local policy.
Summary sources
- Management of Anterior Cruciate Ligament Injuries
Guideline recommendation text consulted
Publication details
- Issuing organisation
- AAOS
- Resource type
- Clinical practice guideline · House clinical summary
- Source setting
- United States
The source check confirms publication details and the linked edition. It does not certify every recommendation or its suitability for an individual patient. Publisher access conditions may apply.