Scope
AAOS guidance distinguishes tear size and depth, repair healing, patient function and response to nonoperative treatment. Physical therapy and surgery can both improve symptoms in selected full-thickness tears, but structural progression and repair failure affect longer-term results. Decisions about procedures, injections and rehabilitation require the stated population and outcome, rather than treating all rotator-cuff disease as interchangeable.
Written by House with AI assistance · AI-assisted source check 29 October 2026.
This is House’s summary of the cited guidance. The source check is not an independent clinician review. Open the publication for complete recommendations, exceptions, evidence grades and later amendments.
Match the diagnosis and treatment to the tear
- Use a combination of clinical examination tests because diagnostic accuracy exceeds that of any single test. MRI, MR arthrography, CT or ultrasound can supplement the clinical examination and radiographs to identify rotator-cuff tears; AAOS rates both statements strong. [1]
- For symptomatic small-to-medium full-thickness tears, discuss both physical therapy and operative repair: both produce meaningful improvement in patient-reported outcomes. The strong recommendation does not require immediate surgery for every tear. [1]
- Explain that full-thickness tears treated nonoperatively may enlarge, with increasing muscle atrophy and fatty infiltration over 5–10 years, despite symptom improvement with therapy. If repair remains viable, consider serial clinical and imaging surveillance to detect progression. [1]
- Healed repairs show better patient-reported and functional outcomes than physical therapy or unhealed repairs, a moderate recommendation. Discuss healing and retear uncertainty when weighing surgery; structural success matters to the expected result. [1]
- For high-grade partial-thickness tears after conservative treatment fails, either completion to a full-thickness tear with repair or transtendinous/in-situ repair can be performed. Debridement or repair after failed physical therapy is supported, and repair can improve outcomes; these are strong recommendations. [1]
- For low- or intermediate-grade partial-thickness tears, physical therapy may improve outcomes. Surgery may improve persistent pain and functional impairment after appropriate nonoperative treatment; this is a consensus option, with no direct comparative trial establishing a universal surgical threshold. [1]
Keep injection benefits and limitations separate
- A single corticosteroid injection with local anaesthetic may improve shoulder pain and function in the short term; injectable NSAIDs may be considered when corticosteroids are not tolerated. This moderate recommendation is not evidence of durable tendon repair. [1]
- Repeated steroid injections may compromise rotator-cuff integrity and later repair, a limited-strength warning. Even a single injection close to surgery may adversely affect outcomes; discuss injection timing with the treating surgeon rather than assuming a safe interval. [1]
- Do not use prolotherapy for full-thickness rotator-cuff tears, a strong recommendation. Hyaluronic-acid injections may be considered only for nonoperative rotator-cuff pathology without tears; that separate option has limited strength. [1]
- Routine PRP injections are not supported for tendinopathy or partial tears, and routine PRP in nonoperative full-thickness tears may not be indicated. Both are limited options; distinguish these injections from platelet products used during repair. [1]
Choose surgery for the relevant outcome
- Do not routinely add acromioplasty for therapeutic benefit during arthroscopic repair of small-to-medium full-thickness tears. This moderate recommendation still allows selected technical needs, such as improving visualisation or access during repair. [1]
- Open and arthroscopic repair have similar healing and patient-reported outcomes beyond 1 year. Arthroscopic-only repair may provide earlier recovery of motion and less short-term pain; the source rates the comparative statement strong. [1]
- Double-row repair is not generally recommended over single-row repair solely to improve patient-reported outcomes. However, it can reduce overall retears and improve outcomes in repairs larger than 3 cm; superiority for full-thickness retears alone is not established. [1]
- Do not add platelet-derived products during repair to improve patient-reported outcomes. Limited evidence supports liquid PRP for reducing overall retear rates, while evidence is insufficient for or against platelet-rich fibrin for retear prevention. [1]
- Marrow stimulation during repair does not improve patient-reported outcomes, although it may reduce retears in larger tears. Its strong evidence statement does not establish that structural improvement will necessarily improve symptoms. [1]
- Human dermal allograft augmentation may lower retears and improve patient-reported outcomes, a moderate recommendation; porcine allograft is not suggested. Discuss added operative time, potential complications and cost when considering augmentation. [1]
- Bioinductive tendon implants can improve retear rates and patient-reported outcomes in the studied repair settings, a strong recommendation. Discuss extra operating time, potential surgical complications and cost; this is not a mandate to use an implant for every tear. [1]
Individualise postoperative rehabilitation and analgesia
- After arthroscopic repair of small-to-medium full-thickness tears, early mobilisation and delayed mobilisation up to 8 weeks produce similar clinical and patient-reported outcomes. Keep the studied tear-size restriction; do not automatically apply this schedule to larger or complex repairs. [1]
- In selected patients after arthroscopic repair, immediate sling weaning to allow comfortable active motion for daily activities need not worsen healing or outcomes. Decide timing jointly with the patient using repair-healing factors; this moderate recommendation is not unrestricted loading clearance. [1]
- After arthroscopic repair of small tears, repeated visits solely to supervise the same independent home exercises have not improved pain or function over one therapist-instruction session followed by home exercise. This moderate recommendation does not exclude skilled multimodal therapy or establish equivalence for larger tears. [1]
- Consider multimodal analgesia or individual nonopioid modalities after repair. The moderate recommendation supports additional pain benefit but does not rank an optimal regimen; assess each medication or procedure’s risks and benefits. [1]
Keep consensus salvage options conditional
- For irreparable tears without arthropathy, consensus options include therapy, biceps procedures, partial repair, tendon transfer, superior-capsule reconstruction, debridement, balloon spacer or nonporcine graft approaches. Evidence is heterogeneous and does not establish one best option; discuss procedure-specific risks and possible revision. [1]
- For massive irreparable tears without arthropathy, reverse arthroplasty may improve outcomes when significant functional loss remains after other treatments fail. This is a consensus option based on limited evidence, rather than an indication for every irreparable tear. [1]
- For massive irreparable tears with glenohumeral arthritis, reverse shoulder arthroplasty may improve outcomes after conservative treatment fails. Explain that symptom resolution and meaningful improvement are not assured and revision may be required; this is also a consensus option. [1]
Limitations and use
- This is a selected clinical decision summary, not a surgical technique manual, injection prescription or complete rehabilitation schedule. Strong, moderate, limited and consensus labels follow AAOS terminology; benefit in a selected study population does not establish a universal indication. No fixed safe interval between steroid injection and surgery is supplied. Implant choice, repairability and rehabilitation loading require individual surgical assessment.
This summary is selective and does not reproduce every recommendation. Apply the source’s population, setting and eligibility criteria, together with clinical judgement and local policy.
Summary sources
- Management of Rotator Cuff Injuries
Selected recommendation material consulted
Publication details
- Issuing organisation
- AAOS
- Resource type
- Clinical practice guideline · House clinical summary
- Source setting
- United States
The source check confirms publication details and the linked edition. It does not certify every recommendation or its suitability for an individual patient. Publisher access conditions may apply.