House
GuidelinesCalculatorsPricingBlog
Ask House ↗
Guidelines↗Calculators↗Pricing↗Blog↗
House
Clinical AIRoundsGuidelinesCalculatorsPricingBlogAboutEditorial policyPrivacyTermsLog in ↗
Clinical intelligence, for physicians.© 2026 House
House
Clinical AIRoundsGuidelinesCalculatorsPricingBlogAboutEditorial policyPrivacyTermsLog in ↗
Clinical intelligence, for physicians.© 2026 House
Back to guidelines
Orthopaedics

Treatment of Clavicle Fractures

AAOS · 2022 edition / updateSource checked 29 October 2026
Read the source publication
House clinical summary

Scope

AAOS guidance for isolated clavicle fractures separates adult displaced midshaft injuries from adolescent and lateral fractures. Adult surgery improves union and early outcomes, but long-term patient-reported outcomes may be similar with non-operative care. Many details of immobilization, risk prediction and implant choice rest on limited evidence or consensus.

Written by House with AI assistance · AI-assisted source check 29 October 2026.

This is House’s summary of the cited guidance. The source check is not an independent clinician review. Open the publication for complete recommendations, exceptions, evidence grades and later amendments.

Discuss early benefit and longer-term tradeoffs

  • For an isolated displaced midshaft fracture in an adult, surgery produces higher union rates and better early patient-reported outcomes than non-operative treatment. Either approach remains reasonable because long-term outcomes and satisfaction are similar. This is the guideline’s strong recommendation. [1]
  • An intramedullary nail and a single plate yield similar long-term clinical outcomes and complication rates. Plate fixation may offer an advantage with comminution; this recommendation has moderate strength. [1]
  • Do not use low-intensity pulsed ultrasound for non-operative management of an acute midshaft fracture: it does not accelerate healing or lower nonunion rates. This is a moderate-strength recommendation. [1]

Use risk information without turning it into a rigid rule

  • Increasing displacement or comminution may raise the risk of nonunion after non-operative treatment in adults. This is a limited-strength option based on low-quality evidence, rather than a universal numerical threshold for surgery. [1]
  • Smoking is associated with higher nonunion rates and worse clinical outcomes, on limited evidence. Include this modifiable risk in treatment counselling. [1]
  • Age and sex alone do not predict reported functional outcomes after midshaft fracture regardless of treatment, according to limited evidence. This finding concerns functional outcomes and does not establish identical union risks for all ages. [1]
  • Upright radiographs may show the degree of midshaft displacement better than supine images. The supporting evidence is low quality and the option has limited strength. [1]

Keep age and fracture location explicit

  • In adolescents aged 18 or younger with displaced midshaft fractures, surgery may provide no benefit over non-operative care: union is similar and implant-removal reoperation is substantial. This is a limited-strength finding and should not be replaced by the adult surgical-benefit statement. [1]
  • For adult lateral Neer type II fractures, lateral locking plates may produce fewer complications and better function than hook plates. This comparison has moderate-strength evidence. [1]
  • Displaced lateral fractures with disruption of the coracoclavicular ligament complex may benefit from operative repair, according to workgroup consensus. This does not make every lateral fracture a surgical indication. [1]

Individualize immobilization and fixation details

  • For most acute clavicle fractures, the workgroup prefers a sling to a figure-of-eight brace. This is a consensus option in the absence of reliable comparative evidence. [1]
  • In adult midshaft fixation, dual plates using one 2.7-mm plate and another 2.7-mm or smaller plate may preserve union while reducing implant removal and secondary procedures compared with a single 3.5-mm plate. This is a limited-strength option. [1]
  • Anterior-inferior plating may require less implant removal than superior plating in adults. Manufacturer-contoured anatomical plates may also reduce removal or deformation compared with other plates. Both statements are limited-strength options, not proof that one implant suits every fracture. [1]

Limitations and use

  • This guideline concerns isolated clavicle fractures. Polytrauma, open injuries, vascular or neurological compromise and other urgent trauma decisions require their own assessment and pathways.
  • The guideline did not establish recommendations for several evidence gaps, including first follow-up radiograph timing, rehabilitation schedules, medial-fracture treatment and some fixation details. Do not invent universal follow-up or return-to-sport intervals from this summary.
  • The summary reports the captured AAOS edition and its evidence strengths; it is not a patient-specific surgical decision or a complete perioperative protocol.

This summary is selective and does not reproduce every recommendation. Apply the source’s population, setting and eligibility criteria, together with clinical judgement and local policy.

Summary sources

  1. 1
    Treatment of Clavicle Fractures

    Guideline recommendation text consulted

Clinical practice guideline

Publication details

Issuing organisation
AAOS
Resource type
Clinical practice guideline · House clinical summary
Source setting
United States

The source check confirms publication details and the linked edition. It does not certify every recommendation or its suitability for an individual patient. Publisher access conditions may apply.

On this page

  • Scope
  • Discuss early benefit and longer-term tradeoffs
  • Use risk information without turning it into a rigid rule
  • Keep age and fracture location explicit
  • Individualize immobilization and fixation details
  • Limitations and use
  • Summary sources
  • Publication details
House
Clinical AIRoundsGuidelinesCalculatorsPricingBlogAboutEditorial policyPrivacyTermsLog in ↗
Clinical intelligence, for physicians.© 2026 House