Scope
The ADA chairside guides address carious-tissue removal and direct restorative materials for vital primary and permanent teeth that have not undergone endodontic treatment. Their recommendations concern lesions requiring restoration without pulp therapy. Choices depend on lesion severity, tooth location and cavity class; most recommendations are conditional with very-low-certainty evidence, making patient circumstances and preferences important.
Written by House with AI assistance · AI-assisted source check 29 October 2026.
This is House’s summary of the cited guidance. The source check is not an independent clinician review. Open the publication for complete recommendations, exceptions, evidence grades and later amendments.
Define the removal approach and individualise the choice
- Selective removal stops at soft or firm dentin; nonselective removal continues to hard dentin. Stepwise removal uses an initial temporary restoration followed later by further removal and a permanent restoration. These are distinct approaches rather than interchangeable labels. [1][2]
- Interpret prioritized options as a ranking informed by effectiveness, resources, acceptability, feasibility and patient preferences. Conditional recommendations require an individual decision consistent with the patient’s values, rather than a single obligatory choice. [1][2]
Primary teeth: tissue removal without pulp therapy
- For moderate lesions on vital primary teeth requiring restoration without pulp therapy, conditionally consider selective removal, nonselective removal or sealing with a preformed crown without removal. Certainty is very low. [1]
- For advanced lesions in this same primary-tooth setting, conditionally prioritize selective removal or sealing with a preformed crown over nonselective or stepwise removal. Certainty is very low. [1]
- Use the no-removal approach only where a preformed crown is indicated. When considering the Hall technique, account for involved surfaces, caries risk and activity, moisture control, behaviour, caregiver preferences and expected time to exfoliation. [1]
Primary teeth: match the material to the restoration
- For moderate or advanced lesions on vital anterior primary teeth without pulp therapy, conditionally use nanocomposite or hybrid resin composite for a Class III restoration. No priority between these options is assigned, and certainty is very low. [1][2]
- For Class V restorations in vital primary anterior or posterior teeth without pulp therapy, conditionally use conventional glass ionomer cement, hybrid resin composite or resin-modified glass ionomer. Certainty is very low and the options are not ranked. [1][2]
- For Class I restorations in vital primary posterior teeth without pulp therapy, conditionally prioritize resin-modified glass ionomer, resin composite, conventional glass ionomer or preformed crowns over compomer or amalgam. Certainty is very low. [1]
- For Class II restorations in vital primary posterior teeth without pulp therapy, conditionally prioritize resin-modified glass ionomer, resin composite or preformed crowns over compomer, conventional glass ionomer or amalgam. Certainty is very low. [1]
Permanent teeth: prioritize selective removal
- For moderate lesions on vital permanent teeth requiring restoration without pulp therapy, conditionally prioritize selective over nonselective removal. Certainty is very low. [2]
- For advanced lesions on vital permanent teeth requiring restoration without pulp therapy, conditionally prioritize selective removal over stepwise or nonselective removal. Certainty is very low. [2]
Permanent teeth: preserve location-specific choices
- For moderate or advanced lesions on vital permanent anterior teeth without pulp therapy, conditionally choose conventional glass ionomer, hybrid resin composite or resin-modified glass ionomer for Class I lingual-pit restorations. Certainty is very low. [2]
- For Class III restorations in vital permanent anterior teeth without pulp therapy, conditionally use nanocomposite or hybrid resin composite. Certainty is very low. [2]
- For Class V restorations in vital permanent anterior or posterior teeth without pulp therapy, conditionally choose conventional glass ionomer, hybrid resin composite or resin-modified glass ionomer. Certainty is very low. [2]
- For Class I restorations in vital permanent posterior teeth without pulp therapy, conditionally prioritize conventional glass ionomer, amalgam, resin composite or resin-modified glass ionomer over compomer. Certainty is very low; assess amalgam suitability separately. [1][2]
- For Class II restorations in vital permanent posterior teeth without pulp therapy, conditionally prioritize amalgam, resin composite or resin-modified glass ionomer over conventional glass ionomer. Certainty is very low, and amalgam precautions still apply. [1][2]
- For moderate or advanced root lesions in vital permanent teeth requiring restoration without pulp therapy, conditionally choose resin-modified or conventional glass ionomer. This recommendation has low certainty, rather than the very-low certainty of the coronal recommendations. [2]
Account for isolation and amalgam precautions
- Glass-ionomer options may be preferable where isolation is difficult, special healthcare needs are present or access to follow-up is unreliable. Conventional glass ionomer may be preferable where light curing is not feasible. [1][2]
- The guides relay the FDA advice to avoid amalgam where possible in children, particularly younger children, and people with neurological disease, impaired kidney function or known allergy to mercury or other amalgam components. Apply this precaution when weighing the listed material options. [1]
Limitations and use
- These chairside recommendations concern vital, non-endodontically treated teeth and restorations without pulp therapy; they do not establish management for pulpal disease.
- The summary does not reproduce all lesion definitions, material variations, crown indications or detailed procedural techniques.
- Most material and tissue-removal choices are conditional with limited certainty; these guides are not a mandate to use the same material for every patient or cavity class.
- This House summary is based on the linked focused or condensed recommendation sources; it does not represent the complete original publication.
This summary is selective and does not reproduce every recommendation. Apply the source’s population, setting and eligibility criteria, together with clinical judgement and local policy.
Summary sources
- Restorative treatments for caries lesions — reviewed source bundle part 1
Selected recommendation material consulted
- Restorative treatments for caries lesions — reviewed source bundle part 2
Selected recommendation material consulted
Publication details
- Issuing organisation
- ADA (Dental)
- Resource type
- Clinical practice guideline · House clinical summary
The source check confirms publication details and the linked edition. It does not certify every recommendation or its suitability for an individual patient. Publisher access conditions may apply.